Welcome!

Eclipse Authors: Pat Romanski, Elizabeth White, Liz McMillan, David H Deans, JP Morgenthal

Related Topics: Linux Containers, Open Source Cloud, Eclipse, Log Management

Linux Containers: Article

There's Simply No Nice Way of Putting This. IBM is an Indian Giver!

IBM Reneges on its Open Source Patent Pledge

There's simply no nice way of putting this. IBM is an Indian giver.

To prevent the commercialization of the long-standing open source project Hercules - which might put some of its mainframe revenues at risk since Hercules is a mainframe emulator - IBM has suddenly claimed - out of the blue - that Hercules infringes at least 173 of its US patents or patent applications - including - get this - patents that it pledged the open source community could use without fear of infringing in 2005.

The "non-exhaustive" list of the 106 patents and 67 patent applications that Hercules allegedly violates fills nine pages of a letter that IBM's mainframe CTO Mark Anzani wrote to Roger Bowler, the creator of the project and the president of TurboHercules SAS, the little French outfit trying to commercialize the widgetry.

In that letter dated March 11, Anzani again rejects the company's proposal that IBM return to its long-established practice of licensing its mainframe operating systems to customers for use on non-IBM hardware on fair and reasonable terms.

For decades until 2006 IBM licensed its mainframe operating systems and associated patents so customers could run the operating systems on plug-compatible hardware from such as Amdahl and Hitachi. TurboHercules simply wants the same kind of license.

The letter didn't reach TurboHercules until after it filed a formal antitrust complaint against IBM with the European Commission two weeks ago. It has accused IBM of tying the use of its dominant mainframe operating systems to its own mainframe hardware.

Anzani's letter also alleges that individual contributors to the Hercules project, some of whom worked at IBM, have made "unauthorized use of proprietary IBM information." He doesn't identify what that proprietary information is.

TurboHercules claims that this is utter twaddle, that IBM itself publishes thousands of pages of technical manuals documenting how to interoperate with its dominant operating systems and that IBM is "abusing its patent portfolio to block open source competition."

It says Hercules has existed for over a decade without any allegation of patent infringement by IBM. Mainframe professionals have used it to learn mainframe skills and test new programs. And IBM itself previously promoted its use in its "Linux for S/390" RedBook published in 2000.

However IBM removed all references to Hercules when it republished the RedBook in 2002. That was after IBM got out from under its consent decrees on both sides of the pond. That was also about the time IBM started getting completely intolerant of any mainframe competition and started driving any would-be rivals out of business.

TurboHercules says that "despite IBM's prior endorsement of Hercules - as well as the release of its own mainframe emulator last year and the purchase of emulation companies Sequent, Platform Solutions and Transitive - it now claims that Hercules is no ‘different from those who seek to market cheap knockoffs of brand-name clothing or apparel.'"

It accuses IBM of breaking two promises: both its pledge not to use its vast patent portfolio as a weapon against open source software projects and its undertaking to the European Commission in 2000 to license its patents to any company on reasonable terms.

The statement Blue made to the EC reads: "IBM has an open patent licensing policy under which we are prepared to license our patents on a non-discriminatory worldwide basis." (See http://ec.europa.eu/internal_market/indprop/docs/comp/replies/ibm_en.pdf.)

IBM used to provide a patent policy on its web site that said, "IBM has an open approach to patent licensing for products in the Information Technology (IT) field and is generally willing to grant non-exclusive licenses under reasonable and non-discriminatory terms and conditions to those who in turn respect IBM's intellectual property (IP) rights."

IBM removed that statement from its web site during its litigation with wannabe mainframer Platform Solutions in 2007. It then acquired Platform Solutions to get it off the market and end the litigation.

TurboHercules claims IBM's current behavior "demonstrates that IBM's support of open source stops the moment those efforts threaten IBM's lucrative mainframe monopolies."

It also says that IBM's attack on Hercules and its individual contributors should strike fear in the hearts of all open source developers everywhere.

"Instead of addressing the important tying claims raised by TurboHercules," it says, "IBM is threatening a patent war against a small open source project to protect its multibillion-dollar mainframe monopolies. If IBM can get away with this, why wouldn't Microsoft, Google, Apple, Oracle and Adobe follow suit against other open source projects?"

Florian Mueller, the guy who started the NoSoftwarePatents campaign that led the European Parliament to reject proposed legislation sanctioning software patents a few years ago, agrees with TurboHercules.

"In market segments," he says, "where IBM has nothing to lose, open source comes in handy and the developer community is courted and cherished. In an area in which IBM generates massive revenues (an estimated $25 billion annually just on mainframe software sales!), any weapon will be brought into position against open source. Even patents, which represent to open source what nuclear arms are in the physical world."

In a blog that calls for a formal investigation and intervention by the European Commission (http://fosspatents.blogspot.com/), Mueller writes:

"Make no mistake: this is not about a simple commercial dispute between IBM and some other vendor. The patents in question, the largest group of which covers the IBM mainframe CPU instruction set, are not specifically connected to what the TurboHercules company is doing beyond the Hercules code base....Other patents that IBM brings into position here cover general address management and virtualization/emulation functionality that would affect many other open source projects as well.

"This is an attack on Free and Open Source Software as a whole. Unless IBM is stopped, other vendors might do the same to protect their turf."

Mueller has been skeptical of IBM's 2005 patent pledge from the very beginning.

"When IBM announced its so-called pledge of 500 patents to the open source community five years ago, I said this was just hypocritical and wasn't going to have any positive effect. Now that half of IBM's profits are at stake, it resorts to anything including patent warfare against open source just to keep customers locked in for more time to come."

He claims the purpose of the patent pledge was merely to appease the community as well as the anti-patent legislators during the debate over European software patents "But it was clear to me from the beginning that IBM fully intended to reserve the right to use patents against open source, and by now it's very apparent that that is the case," he says.

What initially made him suspicious was the number patents IBM pledged.

"It was clear that a quantity of 500 is so miniscule compared to the size of IBM's overall patent portfolio that this was going to be, at best, a drop in the ocean. They still reserved tens of thousands of patents. Compared to that, even nuclear disarmament treaties involve much more substantial percentages of the nuclear arms owned by the parties to such treaties."

Meanwhile, from inside the NoSoftwarePatents campaign he could see that "IBM's love for free and open source software ends where its business interests begin."

"I saw," he says, "IBM as a driving force behind the lobbying for software patents in Europe. We ran into each other from time to time, such as at government roundtables."

Furthermore, "Not only had IBM been a driving force in terms of lobbying but also through its patent filing activity, which aimed at gradually extending the scope of patentable subject matter over here."

Plus, he says, "IBM was also known as a relatively aggressive enforcer of its patents, such as through the infamous ‘IBM patent tax.'"

"They started a long time ago to approach smaller companies (companies that wouldn't have a large enough patent portfolio to do a cross-licensing deal) and told them that in order to steer clear of infringing on any of IBM's countless patents (which are too many for a small or medium-sized company to check on) they should pay IBM a percentage of their total revenue as a patent licensing fee. I don't mean cases where they would have said specifically ‘these are the patents you need to license from us' but really this approach of just scaring people with the sheer breadth and depth of their patent portfolio."

Mueller also claims "IBM is hypocritical about how it wants patents on industry standards to be licensed. In connection with the European Interoperability Strategy and the European Interoperability Framework, IBM and its political allies demand free access to all sorts of patents in the name of interoperability. But the mainframe architecture is also a de facto industry standard and IBM should therefore make its related patents available on the same terms it demands from other industry players."

Anzani's letter can be found at http://openmainframe.org/storage/IBM_reply_TurboHercules_March_2010.pdf and at http://www.scribd.com/doc/29469085/IBM-letter-dated-11-March-2010-to-Tur.... A quick comparison indicates Anzani's list includes at least two patents, US 5,613,086 (an instruction set architecture patent entitled "Method and System for Locking a Page of Real Storage Using a Virtual; Address) and US 5,220,669 (another architecture patent entitled "Linkage Mechanism for Program Isolation"), that IBM pledged to open source use in 2005 (see http://www.ibm.com/ibm/licensing/patents/pledgedpatents.pdf).

More Stories By Maureen O'Gara

Maureen O'Gara the most read technology reporter for the past 20 years, is the Cloud Computing and Virtualization News Desk editor of SYS-CON Media. She is the publisher of famous "Billygrams" and the editor-in-chief of "Client/Server News" for more than a decade. One of the most respected technology reporters in the business, Maureen can be reached by email at maureen(at)sys-con.com or paperboy(at)g2news.com, and by phone at 516 759-7025. Twitter: @MaureenOGara

Comments (0)

Share your thoughts on this story.

Add your comment
You must be signed in to add a comment. Sign-in | Register

In accordance with our Comment Policy, we encourage comments that are on topic, relevant and to-the-point. We will remove comments that include profanity, personal attacks, racial slurs, threats of violence, or other inappropriate material that violates our Terms and Conditions, and will block users who make repeated violations. We ask all readers to expect diversity of opinion and to treat one another with dignity and respect.


IoT & Smart Cities Stories
Contextual Analytics of various threat data provides a deeper understanding of a given threat and enables identification of unknown threat vectors. In his session at @ThingsExpo, David Dufour, Head of Security Architecture, IoT, Webroot, Inc., discussed how through the use of Big Data analytics and deep data correlation across different threat types, it is possible to gain a better understanding of where, how and to what level of danger a malicious actor poses to an organization, and to determin...
The hierarchical architecture that distributes "compute" within the network specially at the edge can enable new services by harnessing emerging technologies. But Edge-Compute comes at increased cost that needs to be managed and potentially augmented by creative architecture solutions as there will always a catching-up with the capacity demands. Processing power in smartphones has enhanced YoY and there is increasingly spare compute capacity that can be potentially pooled. Uber has successfully ...
The deluge of IoT sensor data collected from connected devices and the powerful AI required to make that data actionable are giving rise to a hybrid ecosystem in which cloud, on-prem and edge processes become interweaved. Attendees will learn how emerging composable infrastructure solutions deliver the adaptive architecture needed to manage this new data reality. Machine learning algorithms can better anticipate data storms and automate resources to support surges, including fully scalable GPU-c...
We are seeing a major migration of enterprises applications to the cloud. As cloud and business use of real time applications accelerate, legacy networks are no longer able to architecturally support cloud adoption and deliver the performance and security required by highly distributed enterprises. These outdated solutions have become more costly and complicated to implement, install, manage, and maintain.SD-WAN offers unlimited capabilities for accessing the benefits of the cloud and Internet. ...
Dion Hinchcliffe is an internationally recognized digital expert, bestselling book author, frequent keynote speaker, analyst, futurist, and transformation expert based in Washington, DC. He is currently Chief Strategy Officer at the industry-leading digital strategy and online community solutions firm, 7Summits.
As IoT continues to increase momentum, so does the associated risk. Secure Device Lifecycle Management (DLM) is ranked as one of the most important technology areas of IoT. Driving this trend is the realization that secure support for IoT devices provides companies the ability to deliver high-quality, reliable, secure offerings faster, create new revenue streams, and reduce support costs, all while building a competitive advantage in their markets. In this session, we will use customer use cases...
Machine learning has taken residence at our cities' cores and now we can finally have "smart cities." Cities are a collection of buildings made to provide the structure and safety necessary for people to function, create and survive. Buildings are a pool of ever-changing performance data from large automated systems such as heating and cooling to the people that live and work within them. Through machine learning, buildings can optimize performance, reduce costs, and improve occupant comfort by ...
René Bostic is the Technical VP of the IBM Cloud Unit in North America. Enjoying her career with IBM during the modern millennial technological era, she is an expert in cloud computing, DevOps and emerging cloud technologies such as Blockchain. Her strengths and core competencies include a proven record of accomplishments in consensus building at all levels to assess, plan, and implement enterprise and cloud computing solutions. René is a member of the Society of Women Engineers (SWE) and a m...
With 10 simultaneous tracks, keynotes, general sessions and targeted breakout classes, @CloudEXPO and DXWorldEXPO are two of the most important technology events of the year. Since its launch over eight years ago, @CloudEXPO and DXWorldEXPO have presented a rock star faculty as well as showcased hundreds of sponsors and exhibitors! In this blog post, we provide 7 tips on how, as part of our world-class faculty, you can deliver one of the most popular sessions at our events. But before reading...
Poor data quality and analytics drive down business value. In fact, Gartner estimated that the average financial impact of poor data quality on organizations is $9.7 million per year. But bad data is much more than a cost center. By eroding trust in information, analytics and the business decisions based on these, it is a serious impediment to digital transformation.